How can low-income countries put more money into development?

March 21, 2016
Photo courtesy of Stiftung Solarenergie.

By Michele Learner, Bread for the World Institute

In an earlier Institute blog post, "A New Phrase in Development-Speak: What Is Domestic Resource Mobilization?," we talked about the importance of countries’ ability to gather their own resources for development.

DRM, as domestic resource mobilization is usually called, has the potential, largely untapped, to support efforts to end hunger by raising more funding for the necessary tools - public health and education services, investments in agriculture, social protection plans, and more.

Gathering National Resources

Domestic sources of revenue in sub-Saharan Africa grew from $100 billion in 2000 to nearly $513 billion in 2011. That’s a very rapid increase, especially compared to that of international development assistance from outside sources over the same time period ($20 billion to about $60 billion). As traditional development assistance becomes less important, DRM will be increasingly essential.

We don’t often hear about the details, but it’s clear that “illicit financial flows,” also known as tax evasion, pose a tremendous barrier to development. At an estimated $1 trillion annually, these lost revenues amount to more than international development assistance and foreign direct investment combined. The most common method of evading taxes is invoice fraud. The CSIS overview "Paying for Development: Domestic Resource Mobilization" emphasizes the high stakes: “In 2013 the World Bank noted that ‘there is little doubt’ that [illicit financial flows] have a caustic effect on development, and [in 2014] the African Union noted that ‘it is imperative to curtail’ illicit flows.”

The Institute’s 2015 Crook Fellow, Steven Damiano, looked at how U.S. development assistance could build countries’ ability to raise domestic resources in his briefing paper, "Domestic Resource Mobilization for Development: Ideas for U.S. Policy." The paper discusses U.S. programs, modest as yet, that provide technical assistance and funding for DRM. For example, U.S. support enabled the government of El Salvador to reduce the amount of discretion that individual tax officials have and to form anti-corruption and criminal investigation units. U.S. assistance in strengthening El Salvador's DRM capacity led to increased revenues. These in turn resulted in increased spending on health and education – which, of course, is a critical link between DRM and ending hunger.

Building Public Trust

Perhaps even more important than building systems to assess and collect taxes, countries working to increase their own development resources must build public trust that tax revenues are actually being spent on public goods and services. The CSIS overview notes that accountability to taxpayers requires "stronger oversight by parliaments and a strengthened civil society." Similarly, the July 2015 Third International Conference on Financing for Development discussed building public trust at a side event on DRM. A participating organization explained that “the interests of those who pay taxes and those who save must be taken into account when determining economic policies” and government policies must ensure that the funds are used efficiently.

The OECD, a group of developed countries, has begun to support building public trust on taxes and spending through its Task Force on Tax and Development. It has produced Building Tax Culture, Compliance, and Citizenship: A Global Source Book on Taxpayer Education and plans to support global networking among developing countries on their experiences. There is also a new European Union – Latin American Taxpayer Education Network.

It’s important to emphasize that DRM is not a substitute for investments by donor countries and multilateral organizations, nor a justification for developed countries to reduce their development assistance. DRM is an additional source of funding. All are integral parts of Sustainable Development Goal 17 - strengthening the means of implementation of the other 16 goals and revitalizing the global partnership for development.

Meeting the SDGs requires both revitalizing the global partnership and building public trust in government. The two come together most urgently in countries affected by armed conflict – which brings both investments in development and public trust to a halt. Yet, as the U.N. Peacebuilding Commission points out, "Countries emerging from conflict have difficulty mobilizing domestic resources, while … facing steep challenges to meet expectations for social service delivery.” The Institute will have more to say about development in post-conflict countries in the 2017 Hunger Report, which focuses on fragility.

Michele Learner is associate editor at Bread for the World Institute.

Domestic resource mobilization (DRM) has the potential, largely untapped, to support efforts to end hunger.

Tools
from our Resource Library

For Education

For Faith

  • The Bible on Health as a Hunger Issue

    A brief examination of the biblical approach to health as a hunger issue.

    Includes an introduction to the issue, a Scriptural reflection, practical actions you can take, and a prayer.

  • Sermon by David Beckmann at Duke University Chapel

    Remarks delivered October 1, 2017 at Duke University Chapel in Chapel Hill in North Carolina.

    Thank you for inviting me to preach here at Duke University Chapel. And I especially want to thank the Bread for the World members who have come this morning.

    Bruce Puckett urged...

  • Bread Newsletter January 2016

    In this issue: Another Great Year for Bread; Catholics Begin Observance of Holy Year of Mercy; Serving on ‘God’s Wave Length’ for 39 Years; and more.
     

For Advocacy

  • Grassroots Advocacy Toolkit

    A set of how-to sheets for carrying out advocacy and fact sheets on the current issues Bread for the World is working on.

    For new and current Bread grassroots hunger activists.

    Ideal as a starter toolkit for new Bread activists or as a set of updates for current activists.

    ...

  • Sentencing Reform and Corrections Act of 2017

    Unnecessarily long prison sentences, combined with the lack of rehabilitative programs for people in prison, exacerbate hunger, poverty, and existing inequalities.

    Overly harsh mandatory minimum prison sentences have contributed to the rapid increase of our country’s prison population. The...

  • Health Care Is a Hunger Issue

    Learn more about the principles that Bread for the World supports regarding health reform.

Field

Changing Climate, Changing Farmers

February 7, 2017

Insight

From the Blog